Barry's Free Downloadable Equipment Front Panel Recall/Manuals

Barry's Mix Magazine Equipment And Software Reviews

Barry's Massive Discography And Engineering Career

Barry's Music Connection Magazine Reviews

Barry's Resolution Magazine Reviews

AKG C 451 B Cardioid Condenser Microphone

By Barry Rudolph

AKGAlthough the mic was designed as an homage to its famed ancestry, I'm glad AKG chose not to call the new C-451 B a reissue microphone. The C-451 B is an entire rethinking of the classic C-451 E/CK-1 capsule design, and it sounds better than the original--the result of improved specs, modern componentry and updated construction techniques.

A LITTLE HISTORY

Made from the late '60s through the mid-'80s, the original AKG C-451 C Condenser Modular System (CMS Series) was a best-selling "chameleon" of a mic. It was designed to be adaptable to nearly any purpose; it could be outfitted with any of a whole system of modular components --such as screw-on capsule attenuator pads, extension tubes and swivels -- that greatly increased its versatility. The original mic used the N-46E dual-AC power supply that supplied 12-volt phantom power and had a two-position, bass roll-off filter switch. As I found out by accident in my distant past as a second engineer, the mic would accept up to 52-volt phantom powering without smoking. The original, externally biased CK-1 capsule had an extremely low mass, making the mic insensitive to handling noise making it a favorite for handheld radio and TV use.

For AKG, the C-451 C (the "C" suffix indicates a DIN connector; the "E" designates a standard XLR output) was the first solid-state condenser mic using the then-new Field Effect Transistor (FET) instead of a tube. It replaced both the great-sounding AKG/Norelco C 60 pencil condenser, which used an AC701K tube, and the C-61 with its miniature RCA 7586 Nuvistor tube. With the C-451 EB came a switchable -12dB/octave high-pass filter with flat/75/150Hz positions. Much later, the C-452 EB arrived, which is the same but runs on 48-volt phantom only. Sadly, for economic reasons, AKG discontinued the CMS Series and the CK-1 capsule in 1994.

SO WHAT'S NEW?

AKG's R&D department gathered 12 of what was considered the creme de la creme of vintage CK-1 capsules from around the world to measure and determine their original acoustic properties. The new C-451 B capsule uses a backplate electret, self-polarized design with a three-micron, gold-sputtered Mylar diaphragm suspended just 35 microns from the printed-circuit backplane. The new capsule has the same cardioid polar pattern as the CK-1 because it has the same diameter and thickness.

Capsules Made For The CMS Series
CK-1S: cardioid with +6 dB @ 10 kHz shelf curve

CK-2: original omni-directional

CK-3: hypercardioid

CK-4: figure-of-eight (1-inch double-diaphragm capsule)

CK-5: cardioid with shock mount and windscreen

CK-6: switchable pattern with omni/cardioid/figure-of-eight

CK-8: short shotgun

CK-9: long shotgun

CK-22: newer omni-directional

CK-26: omni-directional (capsule from C-60/61 mics)

CK-28: cardioid (capsule from C-60/61 mics)
Once the CK-1 was reinvented, AKG completely updated the mic's body with Surface Mount Technology (SMT) components on a miniature printed-circuit board and gold-plated XLR and capsule connectors. The old mics were laboriously hand-soldered and prone to intermittents...a well-known fact amongst live sound engineers who shun their use on the road. One new design criteria for the new C-451 E is passing AKG's dreaded drop test, which simulates a 6-foot fall from drum overhead mic stands. This test is repeated six times on each of a group of mics that are randomly selected from the production line.

To make the mic even more rugged, the new capsule is permanently attached to the C-451 B preamp body. A one-piece mic is a welcome feature of the C-451 B, especially to any engineer who, in the middle of a session in a dimly lit studio, has struggled to attach the CK-1 onto the old C-451/452 bodies properly, without cross-threading those very fine, Swiss watch-like threads! However, I do miss the C-451/452's capsule swivel adapters, which were great for sneaking around drum kits.

One thing I don't miss is the need to insert screw-on capsule mic attenuator pads like the ones the old C-451/452 EB mics had. Right on the C-451 B body, near the bass roll-off switch, are -10 and -20dB capsule attenuation switches. Also, both the pad and HP filter switches are improved over the original switches. The new switches are easy-to-see red, and they seem to be better made and easier to change with the tip of a ball-point pen. The old EB's roll-off switches often broke, stuck or disappeared inside the mic body, making it impossible to know (by looking at them) how they were set. Cosmetically, the C-451 B looks similar to the old mics, with sandblasted, all-metal, nickel-plated housing, and engraved wording and symbols. Often, on late '80s-vintage C-451 E mics, the decals (without engraving) wore off.

THE SOUND!

In my A/B tests, I found the C-451 B's new transformerless output improved LF reproduction, especially at higher SPLs. I also noticed more output level than the C-451 E, C-451 EB, C-452 E and C-452 EB. Without going into explicit detail, all the mics sounded great, but overall, the C-451 B is simply more pleasant-sounding than the others. It's warmer than the C-452s, with a better bass roll-off sound, and the bottom end is cleaner than the original. I like the LF sound of the original C-451s, too...just as I like using vintage Neve modules for the sonics of those transformers. The C-451 B still uses the FET design, so everything you'd use the old mics on sounds the same, only better.

You can buy the C-451 B in two ways. As a single mic, it comes with a clip/stand adapter and windscreen in a zippered bag. For this review, I received a stereo pair of two computer-matched microphones. They come with two clips, two windscreens and the H 50 stereo-mounting bar--all in a foam-lined carrying case. "Matched" is an understatement! All new C-451 Bs come with individually measured frequency response (20 to 20kHz, +/- 1.5 dB) curve plots. My two mics' curves are identical; in fact, I can place the two tissue-paper charts (shown in Curves 1 and 2 below) on top of each other and see no differences. AKG uses a computer database comprising all of the frequency response results from a production run of mics. The computer comes up with the best matching pair: Both frequency response and sensitivity measurements must be within +/- 0.5 dB of each other.



451 Curve 1
Curve 1
451 Curve 2
Curve 2


IN THE STUDIO

The most popular studio applications for the C-451/452 have always been drum kits, overheads and acoustic guitar. Small-diaphragm mics excel at accurately reproducing the percussive transients of these instruments. For drums, I always liked the C-451 E on hi-hat and/or snares. Both jobs usually require the attenuator pad, and it is so nice not to have to take the mic down to screw in the -20dB pad when the -10dB pad wasn't enough! The C-451 B, with an increased SPL rating of 135 dB (no pad), would have been fine without a pad on the quieter songs. Even without EQ, both snare drums and hi-hats sound crisp, sharp and "open." The cardioid pickup pattern is not too tight, which provides plenty of ambience for a close-miked instrument, while I can hear more drummer subtleties such as grace notes and stick drags.

The H 50 stereo bar is just the ticket for X/Y or close-spaced cardioid miking of percussion instruments like congas or marimba. In live sound use, I like eliminating one mic stand in a usually crowded percussion-miking setup.

Side-by-Side Comparison of Specifications
C-451 B C-451 E
Cardioid Polar Pattern Cardioid Polar Pattern
Frequency response: 20 to 20kHz +/- 1.5dB (graph supplied) not stated in manual (graph supplied)
Sensitivity: 9 mV/Pa= -41dBv ref. to 1V/Pa -61 dBv ref. to 1V/µbar
Impedance: <200 ohms 200 ohms
Recommended load Impedance: >1000 ohms >500 ohms
Max SPL: 135dB (no pad) 145dB (-10dB pad) 155dB (-20dB pad) 120dB SPL for 0.5%
Equivalent Noise: 18dBA (A-weighted) 22dB (DIN 45 404-RMS)
Dynamic Range: 117dB (A-weighted) Not stated
Pre-attenuation: Switchable to 0dB, -10dB, -20dB in line pad KF-2 -10dB or -20 dB
Powering: 9 to 52 volts phantom 7.5 to 52 volts DC
Operating Temperature: -20 degrees C to +60 C -5 to +160 degrees F
Diameter:3/4 in diameter Length: 6.3 in 4.5 in long (w/o CK-1)

Acoustic guitar recording is exactly the same as with the old mics, except the C-451 B produces tighter, cleaner lows. I also had fewer problems when my guitar player unexpectedly went from quiet finger-picking to full strumming--the mic and recording chain didn't instantly distort. I like the presence of miking close on guitars, but proximity can be a problem. On a Gibson jumbo-body guitar, I put the mic about six inches over the soundhole, aimed toward the bridge, and I used the 150Hz roll-off. Sometimes I used the 75Hz position and rolled off with an equalizer when I needed a song/production/arrangement-specific LF contour. The C-451 B's high-frequency lift is pleasing for acoustic guitar recording and much better than winding on a lot of EQ.

The AKG C-451 B reinforces my fond memories of using the venerable C-451 E with the same but improved sound, and without the old, impractical quirks. The C-451 B retails at $549, or $1,250 for a matched stereo pair.

Thanks to Dan and Eric at LAFX Studios here in NoHo and to engineer/producer Alan Parsons for all their help.

AKG Acoustics, 914 Airport Center Drive, Nashville, TN 37217; 615/620-3800; fax 615/620-3875; www.akg.com/microphones.com.



Barry Rudolph is an L.A.-based recording engineer. Visit his Web site at: WWW.BARRYRUDOLPH.COM




DClick Here To Return To The Mix Directory

This Review Is Copyright © 2002 Through By Future Plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher.  All Rights Reserved.

BACK DOOR! Back To Home Page Back Up To The Top

All Web Page Design Is Copyright © 2002 through By Barry Rudolph